5

I have been using XOWA all these while. But there are other explorers as well (see here). The thing I like about XOWA is that its rendering is impeccable. But the downside is that it needs too much space. Will any of the other explorers give me a better compromise? Other desirable feature should be - if I want to update my wiki, I should just be downloading the update and not the whole wiki all over again. In other words, the option to build one's wiki should be there.

So I need recommendations for Offline Wikipedia Explorer with the following requirements:

  • Reasonably good rendering. Put precisely, all the math, latex and text should be displayed right. I don't care much about table of contents or images and such things.
  • Should take less space than XOWA does. For example, see Disk Space Usage for XOWA. I am willing to compromise on some of the things.
  • And should be convenient to update. To update, I should be downloading only the latest dump and not the whole wiki all over again.

Please advise!

  • 1
    Sorry, this is not a software comparison site. If you can rewrite your software saying "I'm looking for X with requirements A,B,C" that is OK. (Maybe add what you have already tried that does not satisfy). meta.softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/69/… – user416 Jan 19 '16 at 21:08
  • 1
    Welcome to Software Recommendations! Please note that this site doesn't feature requests for product comparisions: SR is about suggesting specific software for specific needs you define. For details, see: Is tool x versus tool y a fair question? – Izzy Jan 19 '16 at 22:55
  • Sorry. Retracted the request for comparison. Re-posed the question as a recommendation request for specific requirements. Thanks for the instructions! – Inspired_Blue Jan 20 '16 at 22:06
2

I'm the XOWA developer, and just wanted to add some information (sadly, I don't have the reputation to comment directly on the question.)

Space usage is definitely a priority in the coming months. I've been spending a lot of time on XOWA Android recently -- where space is at a premium. Several dozen GB is a lot to demand from users, especially in a world where new phones don't have any microSD capability.

Anyway, based on Android, I'm planning on the following:

  • Using lower quality images: Keep in mind XOWA uses the exact images from Wikipedia's articles. However, most users probably don't need full fidelity, and can get by with lower quality. One user suggested a matrix for downscaling and that should reduce usage by 25+ GB. (https://github.com/gnosygnu/xowa/issues/36#issuecomment-169303189)
  • Changing the PC version to use the HTML dumps: This will eliminate the need for having a local wikidata.org instance which will save another 20 GB.
  • Aggressively compressing the HTML dumps: XOWA currently weighs in at about 30 GB for the HTML dumps. I think I can get that down to 20 GB, but it requires quite a bit of code on my side.

All told, I'm targeting a limit of 64 GB in usage. I know that still sounds high, but the compressed wikitext for English Wikipedia is 12 GB, and HTML + images is going to add a lot more. XOWA is at about 120 GB now, and I'm hoping that halving it will be enough. Feel free to say otherwise!

Finally, I realize that complete rebuilds are cumbersome -- especially for Android. I'm working on an incremental update that should just sync differences, though that will take a few months.

Hope you're willing to wait for the upcoming changes. Also, thanks for the praise on the rendering; I really do try to match MediaWiki as closely as possible. If you have any questions, please let me know. Thanks!

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.