14

As I mentioned in this SuperUser question, I'm trying to prepare a PC for educational use by a child, and am trying to find free parental control software to keep installed and ready (their parent might choose to go for some paid application later, but for my part I wish to help them by having a free program ready to use).

From some Googling, it seems that: for Windows, Windows Live Family Safety, Qustodio and K9 seem to be some good options, while for Linux (Ubuntu) "Web Content Control" seems to be the only current option (at least based on this Ubuntu Wiki page).

Since it's a decade-old Pentium 4 PC, the biggest constraint is the resource usage - the more lightweight the program, the better. Other than that, being able to manually add blacklist entries and make exceptions to existing block-lists (if any) would be a requirement. The software must not lump pornographic content and mere profanity and must allow selectively filtering out such categories independently.

Being able to block particular applications with particular schedules, having a simple UI with offline help available, generating easy-to-understand statistics from any monitoring done - these would be nice-to-haves.

If anyone here has experience and expertise in this area, please make a recommendation, whether for for Windows (XP) or Linux, or both.

Improve this question
4
  • Would you be willing to take a recommendation just for windows? Also would it be okay if the software has a yearly fee?
    – aman207
    Mar 2, 2014 at 1:43
  • 4
    Make sure to do the kid a favor, and block facebook and other dumb popular sites.
    – user1071
    Mar 2, 2014 at 4:17
  • @aman207 Just-for-Windows software is definitely welcome. The yearly-fee thing would also be fine if it was like Whatsapp (i.e. pay at the year's end to continue), otherwise it's just that I'd be making a choice of paid software myself instead of leaving it to the parents, which I don't want to do.
    – Sundar R
    Mar 2, 2014 at 17:15
  • Being a linux admin helps, but I've set up kiosks that were very locked down. Creative use of file permissions, forcing firefox to always use a proxy I configured (based on white listing all sites by domain), and of course the squid proxy. Then add in time based 'net access on the router level. Personally I just do my best raising my kids - and inappropriate access hasn't been an issue (yet), other than consuming all available bandwidth when I wanted to do stuff :)
    – ivanivan
    Dec 16, 2016 at 22:31

5 Answers 5

Reset to default
9

Well, if you want a real lightweight solution, create an account with OpenDNS.org and use it as your DNS server. You can set it up on the computer or at your router. Set categories to block, sites to white-list or black-list.

Of course this does nothing to limit time on the internet, nor what can be run locally. On the other hand, it has absolutely no overhead on your machine, because it isn't running on your machine. Free is good, too.

Improve this answer
1
  • 3
    If you're doing this on a router, many routers have per-client time restrictions as an option, which might work well with opendns on the router.
    – Journeyman Geek
    Mar 2, 2014 at 3:30
1

I have old 1.5 Hrz Celeron-based notebook with 512Mb of RAM and WinXP. Installed Work Examiner monitoring tool for about a year ago to control when my son is on it. I've enabled adult blocking policies (content-based) and see all chat conversations.

It can be used w/o annual fees. Anyway, costed about $60 per PC I assume... So, that would be one of the solutions to choose from.

Improve this answer
1
  • Thanks for your answer, Darek! Mind to edit it and add some details on your experiences? What especially do you like about the software, and what maybe you dislike? Please read our discussion on what makes an answer high quality to see if you can incorporate some of these improvements into your answer. That would be great!
    – Izzy ♦
    Mar 7, 2014 at 12:48
1

You can try AVG's solution called Family Safety. Although its costs $50 per year (you have the option to renew at the end of the year or you can let it expire), per computer, it is an excellent piece of software with low system requirements. It only requires 128mb of ram, and a 1Ghz Pentium processor. I used to use it on my Pentium 4 3.5Ghz with 2.5gb of ram and it ran seamlessly with other applications. It is compatible with Windows XP, Vista, and 7.

Features:

  • Automatic blocking of internet based on age or you can set categories
  • Manually block webpages and whitelist others
  • Different profiles for each child
  • Monitor social network chats for possible bullying messages
  • Ability to receive reports via text message or email on what child has been searching or what webpages a child has been on (aka statistics)
  • Computer schedules for each child
  • Block certain applications for each child
  • Ability to remotely change the settings for each child
  • Ability to protect the whole wireless network (family safety has to be running on a computer connected wirelessly)
  • Also includes iOS and Android apps

Downsides

I wish it would send you daily reports but it only send them to you once it detects suspicious activity for things like anti-bullying.

Screenshot:

Screenshot 1

Improve this answer
1

Here https://github.com/vasyaod/parental-control a simple daemon for Linux is provided with following features:

  • flexible week schedule
  • convenient yaml config
  • supporting multiple users
  • time counter
  • daily limits
  • simple web UI (installation of UI is not obligatory) which allows to see
    • state of consumed time for current date
    • statistics of consumed time

enter image description here

Improve this answer
-2

My elder son is clever enough to disable the build-in Windows control, so I recommend everyone to chose some good parent-control program. I, myself, love Time Boss. It allows me not to just block, but also to reduce access to some sites, so now he can plat MMO, but not for the whole day. The program is relatively cheap, if you take into account, that the new version (3.11) comes with licenses for 3 computers.

Improve this answer
1
  • Welcome to Software Recommendations! And thanks for sharing your recommendation. However, your post lacks some basic information (e.g. a link to the mentioned software) to be considered a high quality answer. Please read our discussion on what makes an answer high quality to see if you can incorporate some of these improvements into your answer.
    – Izzy ♦
    May 14, 2014 at 11:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.