2

I've been using KDE Skrooge budgeting app for a few years but now I switched to macOS.

I'm looking for app similar to Skrooge and I'd like it to be / have:

  • open source (not that important)
  • desktop app (no online web app)

GNU Cash is a no-go.

Why GNU Cash is a no-go recommendation?

This is off course my opinion based on many years of using Skrooge but trying it for a while I didn't find it as good as Skrooge.

  • having several categories in Skrooge (bills, food, etc) after importing data to GNU Cash I ended up with as many accounts as I had in Skrooge. In Skrooge I was using following accounts (regular bank account, pre-paid card, and wallet - it was implemented as my feature request!). An item can be added to any category to any account - so for example at the end of month you can see how much you spent on food across all accounts
  • The interface is for me kind of 'raw'; (treat is as very subjective opinion)
  • GNU Cash couldn't handle the following scenario: week ago, when I usually deal with the budget, I enter all bills and prices, or bank accounts. By accident the food category (let's say $X) landed not in wallet account (as I prefer to use 'real' money), but my main bank account. In Skrooge it'd only required to update account field, but in GNU Cash (after importing data) I ended up with messed up data that was no longer 'in-sync').

What I like in Skrooge?

  • budget feature and comparing real and planned budget
  • transfer from one account to the other (like drawing money from cash machine)
  • no need for online account
  • the author, or one of them (Stephane Mankowski), implements a feaure request in a very short period of time if he finds it useful. It's not a do it know for free!, dude, or I'll kill you! As far I remember he implemented at least 2 (TWO) feature requests.

Why Skrooge for Mac is a no-go?

The docs says that the app for Mac is for only testing purposes so I took it for granted. If it is not that bad, please let me know.

Mac version is only available from macports. As Skrooge is a KDE app, in order to install it requires additional KDE dependencies.

3
  • Is there a particular reason GNUCash is a no-go? Knowing the reason it doesn't work for you will help others answer the question.
    – Colin McFaul
    Dec 6, 2014 at 21:42
  • What's wrong with their OS X version? skrooge.org/macos_installation
    – littleadv
    Dec 6, 2014 at 22:49
  • Question has been updated. If Software Recommendations is a better place for this kind of questions, I can move it there, but I'd like to avoid cross-posting.
    – wryrych
    Dec 13, 2014 at 12:43

0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.